Shiny on the Outside - Opening Ceremonies
Alas, another negative comment about the opening ceremonies. :( I just hate to do this but it really irritates me.
There was a great section of the ceremonies where a 9 year-old girl sang in front of the entire stadium. It was great singing and it was impressive to see that from such a young person in such a high pressure setting. Everyone was amazed. Turns out that it was also a fabrication. *grumble*
Apparently, the little girl (7 years old) that endured to the end of the singing contests and was chosen for having the best voice and ability was axed at the last minute because she wasn't cute enough. They replaced her with another girl (of undeniable cuteness) and in a great injustice, had the original girl's voice be the one that was broadcast throughtout the stadium (and the world). Turns out that this was just another lip-syncing effort like so many other singers in the past.
The Chinese say that they had their reasons for this but I don't agree. Packaged performances (like movies, etc.) are known to be "constructed" to provide the best possible experience. Live performances are invogorating and astonishing because they happen in real life. The reality (and integrity) are part of the what makes them appealing to people. Without that feeling of authenticity, there's no reason to enjoy these events in person. Just give me a movie and tell me it's a movie. Don't "pretend" you've given me authenticity.
Of course, the whole notion of authenticity may be out-dated and it's certainly not an overriding concern in China. On a variety of levels, China operates under the assumption that if it looks the same on the outside, then it must work the same on the inside. Much of the miracle of China is built on this assumption and rest assured, all gilded ages (and cultures) have eventually collapsed under the weight of the facades they build up. Just because it's shiny on the outside doesn't mean it isn't rotting underneath.